Short answer: hydronic balancing with circuit balancing valves (CBVs) means reading the pressure drop across each valve, converting it to flow with the valve's flow coefficient, and throttling valves until every coil, branch and riser carries its design flow within the tolerance in the specification, commonly ±10%, or ±5% on stricter projects.[1][2] It is done once the system is filled, cleaned, vented and running at design pump speed, and it ends with the pump head reduced and a report listing design flow, measured flow, pressure drop and handwheel setting for every valve.[1]
What does a circuit balancing valve actually do?
A CBV (also called a circuit setter or manual balancing valve) is a calibrated throttling valve with two pressure test ports. The balancer connects a differential pressure meter to the ports, reads the pressure drop (ΔP) and converts it to flow using the valve's flow coefficient at its current handwheel setting, taken from the manufacturer's data.
The flow coefficient Cv is the flow of water, in US GPM at 60 °F, that passes through the valve with a 1 psi pressure drop. For water, flow = Cv × √ΔP, with ΔP in psi.[3] Illustration only: at a setting where Cv = 5.0 and a measured ΔP of 2.0 psi (13.8 kPa, 4.6 ft of water), the valve passes 5.0 × √2.0 ≈ 7.1 GPM (0.45 L/s).
Because flow varies with the square root of ΔP, a small reading error at a low pressure drop becomes a large flow error. That is why the instrument, its calibration date and the minimum readable ΔP published for the valve matter.
What has to be ready before hydronic balancing starts?
Balancing starts from as-built drawings, with filters and strainers cleaned, the system de-aerated and pressurised, and the pump checked.[1] On site, that means:
- System filled, flushed and vented; strainers and start-up screens cleaned
- Pumps running at design speed, rotation verified; VFDs at a known, confirmed speed
- Control valves driven fully open through the BAS, with the controls contractor available
- Every CBV installed in the right flow direction, with test ports accessible (not insulated over, ceiling access available)
- A design flow schedule for coils, terminal units, risers and pumps, plus the model and size of each CBV
- Flow tolerance confirmed with the designer before starting[1]
Missing items on this list are the most common cause of a return visit, which is usually billed as extra work.
How does the proportional balancing method work?
The proportional method is the one most specifications have in mind. In summary:[2]
- Open all control and balancing valves fully and run the pump at design speed.
- Find the most hydraulically remote terminal (often on the top floor, farthest from the riser) and leave its CBV fully open as the reference.
- Throttle the other terminals on that branch until they match the reference.
- Repeat branch by branch, then riser by riser, keeping the most remote one fully open.
- Throttle the main CBV to reach 100% of design total flow.
- Measure the main CBV pressure drop throttled and fully open: the difference is excess pump head. Trim the impeller to remove it, then reopen the main valve and confirm design flow.
- Return the control valves to automatic.
On a variable-speed pump, the head is set by speed rather than by trimming the impeller.[1] The compensated method works on the same principle and visits each valve only once, at the cost of a three-person crew and two instruments.[1]
Two checks help spot a poor result. IMI recommends a pressure drop of about 3 kPa (0.44 psi, about 1 ft of water) across the balancing valve on the index circuit, and notes that properly sized valves are normally more than 50% open.[1] When many valves end up almost closed, the pump head is higher than the system needs.
What tolerance is acceptable?
The project specification governs, usually in Division 23, section 23 05 93. As a reference, IMI treats ±10% of design flow as a good tolerance for heating and cooling, ±5% as very good but harder and more costly to reach, and advises against specifying more than ±10% unless room comfort is of minor importance.[1] Many commissioning authorities ask for ±5%.[2] A ±5% requirement on a large system takes more time, so read it before pricing.
Which standard does hydronic balancing follow?
ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 111-2024 provides uniform procedures for measuring, testing, adjusting, balancing, evaluating and reporting the performance of building HVAC systems in the field, including hydronic systems.[4] Specifications also commonly call up AABC or NEBB procedures; follow the one your specification names.
What should a hydronic balancing report include?
- Balancing method, instrument, serial number, calibration date and the person responsible[1]
- For each CBV: tag, size, design flow, measured flow in GPM and L/s, % of design, measured ΔP in psi or kPa, and final handwheel setting[1]
- Pumps: design and measured flow and head, suction and discharge pressures, motor amperage and voltage, VFD frequency or impeller diameter
- Entering and leaving water temperatures at coils where the specification asks for them
- Deficiencies: valve missing or installed backwards, ports inaccessible, strainer blocked, air in the system, control valve not opening, ΔP too low to read
The recorded handwheel settings are what allow a valve to be returned to its balanced position after it is closed for service.
Is domestic hot water recirculation part of the scope?
Sometimes. Balancing valves on DHW recirculation branches are read and set the same way, but they may sit in the plumbing scope rather than in the Division 23 TAB section. Confirm where they are specified before the quotation, so they are neither missed nor priced twice.
Need hydronic balancing on an Ottawa–Gatineau project?
GreenTech Air Balancing balances heating water, chilled water and glycol systems, pumps and coils for mechanical contractors, engineers and building owners in Ottawa, Gatineau and Eastern Ontario, and documents the results in a TAB report. See our hydronic water balancing service, or send us your mechanical drawings and specifications for a quotation.
This article is general information, not engineering advice. TAB field measurements document system performance at the time of testing; design and code compliance remain the responsibility of the design professional, the owner and the authority having jurisdiction.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- IMI Hydronic Engineering — Balancing protocol (preparation, methods, tolerances, documentation and analysis)
- R. Brandon, Hydronics column, Mechanical Business, April 2008 (Armstrong Fluid Technology) — proportional balancing in 10 steps
- Belimo — What is Cv, and how do I calculate it?
- ANSI Webstore — ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 111-2024, Measurement, Testing, Adjusting, and Balancing of Building HVAC Systems


